Controversy Surrounding System to Determine Truck Crash Accountability

The sheer size and weight of commercial trucks make truck collisions some of the most deadly types of motor vehicle accidents. The potential danger posed by 18-wheeler accidents has led the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) to track such crashes and rate carriers’ safety performances. Now, those in the trucking industry are advocating for changes to this system. The FMCSA tracks truck accidents as part of its Compliance Safety Accountability (CSA) program. Under the program, part of a carrier’s safety rating is based on the number of crashes its trucks are involved in, regardless of whether its truck drivers are at fault for the accidents. The agency maintains that such crash data, with or without fault, is a reliable predictor of a carrier’s future safety performance.

Approaches to Determining Truck Accident Fault

Some of those in the trucking industry, including the America Trucking Associations (ATA), want the FMCSA to change its system for measuring crash data and place emphasis on which driver is at fault for a wreck. The FMCSA has been considering this approach, and conducted a study to see if it would be feasible to use police reports to determine fault in truck accidents. Since the study was completed, the ATA has repeatedly requested that the FMCSA release the results. “To live up to its goal to be open and transparent, FMCSA should release the results of the study, identify the specific concerns that caused it to place the planned solution on hold, and commit to a timeline for addressing the issue,” explained the ATA President. The FMCSA has refused, saying the findings were preliminary and require further review. In the meantime, the carrier safety rating system has remained in place and unchanged.

The Causes of Truck Accidents

Although 18-wheeler accidents may sometimes be caused by the drivers of passenger vehicles, often the truck driver is at fault. A variety of factors may contribute to a truck driver causing an accident, including: driver fatigue, substance abuse, speeding, distracted driving, overloaded tractor-trailers and disrepair of tractor-trailers. If you or a loved one has been involved in an 18-wheeler accident caused by a negligent truck driver, contact an experienced personal injury attorney. A New York City personal injury lawyer can investigate your case, advocate on your behalf and help ensure you receive the compensation you deserve.

Archives

FindLaw Network

Meet The Jaroslawicz & Jaros Team

David Jaroslawicz
David Jaroslawicz »

David Jaroslawicz, the principal partner of Jaroslawicz & Jaros, is a member of the New York, Florida and California bars. He has been …

Abraham Jaros
Abraham Jaros »

Abraham Jaros, co-partner and founder of Jaroslawicz & Jaros, is a seasoned and successful trial lawyer who began his career over 40 years ago...

Roger Lavinsky
Roger Lavinsky »

Roger Lavinsky, a senior associate of the firm, has been with Jaroslawicz & Jaros for twelve (12) years and has been practicing personal …

Michael Levine
Michael Levine »

Michael Levine is a senior trial attorney at Jaroslawicz and Jaros and has been with the firm for almost four (4) years. He …

Tom Miller
Tom Miller »

Tom Miller joined Jaroslawicz and Jaros as an Associate in 2017. He graduated from Roger Williams University School of Law in 2011 and is admitted to practice in New York and New Jersey.

Samantha Ribeiro
Samantha Ribeiro »

Daniel Perrone recently joined Jaroslawicz & Jaros as an Associate in 2017. He graduated from St. John's University School of Law …

David Tolchin
David Tolchin »

David Tolchin is a senior associate of the firm, has been with Jaroslawicz and Jaros for eighteen (18) years since graduating from law …

Mariel-Crippen
Mariel-Crippen »

Mariel Crippen joined Jaroslawicz and Jaros as an Associate in 2018. She graduated from St. John's University …

Elizabeth Eilender
Elizabeth Eilender »

Elizabeth Eilender has been “Of Counsel” to the firm of Jaroslawicz & Jaros for twenty four (24) years. She is a …

Michelle Holman
Michelle Holman »

Michelle Holman, is a senior associate of the firm, has been with Jaroslawicz and Jaros for almost eight (8) years. She is a …

Awards & Recognition

AVVO Rating | 9.8 | Abraham Jaros | Top Attorney
10 Best law Firms | 2014-2016
Top NY Verdicts of 2008
Top Attorneys In New York
The National Trial Lawyers
Super Lawyers | Excellence In Practice 2016
American Association for Justice
Super Lawyers
Top 100 Trial Lawyers
10 Best law Firms | 2015
American Institute Of Personal Injury Attorneys
Lead Counsel Rated
BBB: Accredited Business
Expertise | Best Car Accident Attorneys in New York City | 2017
10 Best Badge | Attorney Client Satisfaction